3 Comments
User's avatar
Todd McKeever's avatar

Lee, the part that stays with me is that a leader never gets to sit on the other side of himself. At mid-career there is a second problem: the longer the reputation, the more the room edits itself before it speaks, so the feedback a senior leader hears gets cleaner as it gets less true. The disagreement test is the honest one. I would add: ask what happened to the last person who disagreed, six months later. The room remembers that longer than the meeting.

Lee Whitmore's avatar

Thanks for adding that brilliant test, Todd. Asking what happened to the last person who disagreed six months later cuts right through the performative layer of leadership. As you noted, the room remembers the actual consequences of disagreement far longer than the meeting itself. If a senior leader's reputation causes the team to edit their feedback, establishing a visible track record of rewarding dissent is the only structural fix to stop the truth from being filtered out.

Todd McKeever's avatar

Lee, I agree. And I think the real test comes after the disagreement, when that person is considered for the next important assignment or promotion. Leaders can praise someone for speaking up in a meeting and quietly penalize them six months later. People notice who gets trusted with responsibility afterward. That’s where a leader’s stated openness either becomes part of the culture or loses its credibility. The next disagreement is shaped by what happened to the last person who spoke up.