I was speaking with Alison Brenner recently, and early in our conversation, she dropped a quiet, brilliant observation. She pointed out that as a leader, you are the only person in the room who never gets to experience being on the other side of you.
You might know your industry inside out. You might understand your company strategy better than anyone. But the one thing you cannot evaluate on your own is how your presence lands with your team.
In leadership, we spend a lot of time judging ourselves by our own good intentions. If we mean well, we assume we are doing well. But there is a distinct gap between what we intend to achieve and what our people actually experience. The intention-impact gap is where trust breaks down, where communication fails, and where good leaders lose their connection to reality.
The Human Side of Technological Disruption
This gap becomes highly visible during periods of rapid change. Look at how organisations are handling the current wave of AI adoption.
In the boardroom, the conversation is full of excitement. Leaders see a shiny new efficiency tool. They intend to streamline processes and give their teams a competitive edge. Down the hall, the reality feels entirely different. Employees are wrestling with cognitive overload, anxiety about their relevance, and the sheer burden of learning a completely new way of working while keeping up with their existing responsibilities.
Treating AI adoption purely as a systems upgrade ignores the reality of the situation. It is a human change management challenge. Your intention might be to make the company faster. Your impact might be overwhelming your best people and eroding their sense of autonomy. As I discuss in Enhanced Leadership, navigating change effectively requires us to pay close attention to the human elements of execution. We have to look past the technology and manage the uncertainty it creates.
The Illusion of Psychological Safety
The intention-impact gap also corrupts how we think about workplace culture. A common trap for well-meaning leaders is attempting to solve cultural issues by declaration.
You cannot simply declare a psychologically safe space. You cannot put it in a memo, write it on a wall poster, or announce it at an all-hands meeting and expect it to exist. Safety is measured strictly by behaviour.
The real test of your culture is not what you say. It is what happens when someone disagrees with you.
Consider these questions:
Who brings you bad news?
Who is willing to admit a costly mistake in your presence?
What happens in the room immediately after someone challenges your perspective?
If everyone around you is nodding along and telling you what a great job you are doing, you do not have psychological safety. You have compliance. You are flying blind, and there is vital information out there that everyone knows except you.
Practical Implications for Leaders
Closing the intention-impact gap requires personal accountability and a willingness to seek out the hard truths. Here is what you should focus on changing.
Notice your first reaction When a crisis hits or someone delivers critical feedback, your reaction in that exact first second dictates the real culture of your team. That moment of pressure shows people what is actually safe. If you react defensively, people will stop telling you the truth. If you pause, regulate your emotion, and show curiosity, you lead by example and build immediate trust.
Ditch the feedback sandwich When it comes to giving feedback to others, water it down at your peril. Delivering a difficult message wedged between two empty compliments damages your credibility and confuses the recipient. Authenticity requires you to be constructive, kind, and direct. Before you have a difficult conversation, pause. Ask yourself how you want the person to feel about their relationship with you when they leave the room. Deliver the truth, but do it with genuine respect and clarity.
Hunt for your blind spots The strongest leaders do not assume that good intentions equal good impact. They actively seek feedback to bridge the gap. You have to build reliable feedback loops into your routine. Ask specific questions, listen without defending yourself, and look for the patterns in what people tell you.
Implications for Coaches
As coaches, our primary job is to help leaders see what they cannot see on their own. We have to help them step out of their own perspective.
Spot the defensive pivot Listen carefully for the ‘good intention’ defence. When a client defends a poor outcome or a fractured relationship by explaining what they meant to do, gently pivot them back to the impact they actually had. Help them separate their intent from the result.
Ask diagnostic questions Help your clients measure their culture through actual behaviour. Ask them who was the last person to disagree with them in a meeting. Ask them to describe exactly what happened the last time a team member made a significant mistake. The answers will reveal the true level of trust in their environment.
Rehearse the critical moments Help clients practice their first response to bad news. Role-play the exact moment they receive critical feedback. If they can learn to manage their own emotional reaction and respond with curiosity rather than defence, they will transform the way their team communicates.
The Power of Curiosity
Excellent leadership always comes back to a combination of humility and curiosity. It requires accepting that you do not know everything, especially when it comes to your own blind spots. When you are willing to admit a mistake, adjust your approach, and align your impact with your intentions, you give your team the confidence to do their best work.
To explore these themes further, listen to my full conversation with Alison Brenner on the latest episode of the Level Up Leadership podcast. We dig deeper into these dynamics, and she shares more about her brilliant work at InnerVue.
Until next time, keep leading, keep learning, and keep levelling up!



Lee, the part that stays with me is that a leader never gets to sit on the other side of himself. At mid-career there is a second problem: the longer the reputation, the more the room edits itself before it speaks, so the feedback a senior leader hears gets cleaner as it gets less true. The disagreement test is the honest one. I would add: ask what happened to the last person who disagreed, six months later. The room remembers that longer than the meeting.