The Missing Link in AI Adoption
Why Your People Matter More Than Your Tech
I make no secret of my position as an AI enthusiast. I have spent a lot of time and energy advocating for the adoption of these tools, encouraging leaders to lean into the discomfort of change, and championing the incredible potential of this technology. It is a passion that drove me to write my book, Enhanced Leadership, which focuses entirely on how to lead effectively in an AI era.
However, I recently encountered a piece of research that offered a deeper layer of understanding to my own work. A groundbreaking survey from the Boston Consulting Group (BCG) and Columbia Business School made me pause and reflect.
While I remain faithful to the cause of AI adoption, these insights forced me to appreciate the genuine thoughts and positions of the people on the ground. The data suggests that for all our enthusiasm, we might be missing the most critical component of the transition: the human element.
You can read the full report here: Employee Centricity in an AI World.
Here is my take on what the report says.
The Core Concepts: Centricity and The Gap
To understand why some companies thrive with AI while others stumble, we need to look at two distinct concepts highlighted in this research.
Employee Centricity
This is the foundational metric of the study. Employee centricity is defined as prioritising employees to the same extent as customers and shareholders. It involves listening to feedback, providing fair opportunities for advancement, treating staff with respect, and supporting them both professionally and personally.
The Perception Gap
The survey identifies a stark divide between the C-suite and the shop floor. Senior leaders are often optimistic and confident, whereas individual contributors are frequently fearful or indifferent. This gap in perception extends to how well-informed employees feel and how enthusiastic they are about the changes ahead.
Peeling Back the Layers of AI Sentiment
As someone who lives and breathes this topic, the disparity in the numbers was startling. Senior leaders are overwhelmingly positive about AI integration. In fact, 96% of executive leaders express positive emotions such as empowerment, excitement, and hope. Conversely, only 63% of individual contributors share this sentiment. While the boardroom is buzzing with excitement, and it is an excitement I often share, the front line is wrestling with fear of job loss, distrust, and indifference.
The danger arises when leaders assume their teams share their enthusiasm. The data shows that the more senior you are, the more likely you are to overestimate how informed your employees are. There is a massive 51 percentage point gap between leaders who believe employees feel well-informed and the employees who actually do. Similarly, there is a 45 percentage point gap regarding enthusiasm for AI adoption.
Leaders also dramatically overestimate their own culture. There is a 42 percentage point gap between executives and individual contributors regarding how ‘employee-centric’ the organisation actually is. Leaders think they are providing a supportive environment, yet their teams largely disagree.
The Strategic Value of Putting People First
You might ask why this ‘soft’ metric of employee centricity matters for ‘hard’ tech implementation. As I argue in Enhanced Leadership, you cannot divorce technical progress from human development. The data supports this view entirely: employee centricity is the primary driver of AI maturity. Organisations that are mature in employee centricity are 7x more likely to be AI mature compared to those just beginning their journey.
The benefits extend far beyond simply implementing new software. Employees at human-centric organisations are significantly more likely to feel enthusiastic and optimistic about AI. They are also 92% more likely to feel well-informed about the strategy. When people feel valued and heard, they stop resisting change and start driving it.
Furthermore, this approach pays dividends in general organisational health. Staff at these companies are 43% more likely to be motivated to give their best work and 36% more likely to see themselves working there in a year’s time. They even rate their organisation’s financial performance higher than competitors.
Takeaways for Leaders
If you are leading a team or an entire organisation, this data serves as a critical wake-up call. The higher you climb, the harder it becomes to see the reality on the ground.
Audit Your Optimism: Recognise that your view is likely rose-tinted. If you think your team is excited and well-informed, statistical probability suggests you are overestimating the situation by nearly 50%.
Prioritise Internal Customer Service: You must treat your employees with the same rigour and care as your external customers. This means actively listening to them and acting on their feedback.
Communicate Relentlessly: A massive gap exists regarding how well-informed employees feel. You cannot simply announce an AI strategy once. You must engage in a continuous dialogue to convert fear and indifference into empowerment and curiosity.
Takeaways for Coaches
For those of us coaching leaders, this research provides a powerful framework for intervention.
Highlight the Blind Spots: Use this data to challenge your clients. When a leader says their culture is strong, ask for the evidence. Remind them of the 42 percentage point gap that typically exists between leadership perception and employee reality.
Support the Middle: Middle managers are in a precarious position. Their sentiment scores often sit halfway between the fear of contributors and the hope of executives. They are the bridge. Coaching efforts should focus on equipping these managers to translate strategy into safety for their teams.
Redefine Tech Readiness: Help your clients understand that tech readiness is actually culture readiness. If they want to adopt AI successfully, they must first work on respect, fairness, and support.
Closing Thoughts
This research was a welcome addition to my thinking. It reminded me that while I advocate for an AI-enhanced future, I must remain grounded in the present reality of the workforce. The evidence is clear: speed comes from trust. If you want your organisation to move fast, you must slow down enough to bring your people with you.
I remain as enthusiastic as ever about the potential of AI, but I am now even more convinced that the path to Enhanced Leadership lies in appreciating people’s genuine thoughts and positions.
I encourage you to look at your own teams this week.
Are you assuming they are ready, or are you doing the work to ensure they feel safe, informed, and valued?
The future belongs to the employee-centric.
Level Up Leadership is a passion project in my spare time. I enjoy doing it, and I intend to keep these articles and podcasts free. However, the software and equipment I use isn’t free! So, if you are enjoying this content and would like to make a donation, you can do so by clicking this button. Thank you.