Navigating the Daily Swirl
Your Priority Compass
Do you ever feel like you’re constantly putting out fires, overwhelmed by a cascade of tasks and struggling to truly make your mark?
You’re not alone. This challenge is incredibly common for middle managers, and it’s one of the main areas I’m consistently asked to coach aspiring leaders on.
Why? Because mastering prioritisation is fundamental to your professional growth and impact.
I’ve refined my own approach to this over many years, from my early days in retail and logistics to my current role as a senior leader in public service. The ‘Priority Compass’ is the result – a self-directed coaching manual designed to bring clarity, purpose, and control to your busy workload.
This article is the first in a two-part series on effective prioritisation. While the ultimate goal is to move beyond simply reacting to demands – finding ways to create time for proactive work, and knowing when ‘good enough’ is truly ‘done’ – we must first build a strong foundation. This piece will focus on mastering the essentials of managing your immediate ‘to-do list’ with precision, paving the way for greater strategic impact.
Why Prioritisation Feels So Hard (and How to Get Smarter)
We’ve all encountered advice on distinguishing between urgent and important tasks. It sounds straightforward, right? Yet, in the real world of a middle manager, it’s rarely that simple. We operate in dynamic environments where new challenges constantly emerge, and the latest email often screams louder than the crucial project for next quarter.
This is precisely why your judgment, your experience, and your unique insight into your team’s operations are absolutely key to effective prioritisation. The Priority Compass isn’t a rigid rulebook; it’s a framework designed to enhance your ability to make smart, impactful decisions. It’s based on real-world experience, not just theory.
The Critical Difference: Importance vs. Urgency
One of the biggest pitfalls I observe is confusing Importance with Urgency. They are not the same, and understanding the difference is crucial for your effectiveness. We often react to what’s loudest, but is it truly what matters most?
Let’s start with Importance. This is where you bring your understanding of your team’s goals, your department’s objectives, and the wider organisational priorities. Just because a request lands with a tight deadline doesn’t automatically make it important. To truly assess importance, the Compass prompts a series of practical questions, guiding you to consider the value to key stakeholders:
How severe are the potential consequences of not doing this work, or doing it late? Think about the impact on your team’s performance, client satisfaction, or even direct service delivery.
How certain is it that there will be a consequence if this work isn’t done, or is done late?
How swift could those consequences be?
By consistently asking these questions, you begin to quantify the true weight of a task. The Compass then guides you to rank tasks from ‘Critically Important’ (where severe, immediate, and certain consequences loom) down to ‘Very Low Importance’ (an ‘added value’ task that won’t impact core operations or strategic priorities). Understanding these levels is crucial because it allows you to make informed decisions about where your valuable time and energy truly need to go.
Now, let’s turn to Urgency.
Beyond just an official deadline, urgency is about understanding dependencies – what needs to happen before you can start this piece of work, or what other work can’t commence until this task is complete? For larger pieces of work, the Compass advocates breaking them down into smaller components and assigning ‘nominal deadlines’ to each part. These are your proactive, internal milestones, ideally set earlier than any external deadlines. This foresight allows you to create vital buffer time, reducing stress and enabling a more controlled, less reactive pace.
Strategic ‘Zoning’ and Thinking Ahead
The power of the Priority Compass culminates in its ‘zoning’ – a mental matrix where importance and urgency intersect. The core insight here is key: while every task inexorably moves towards higher urgency over time, its importance typically remains constant.
By leveraging this understanding, you can forecast the trajectory of initiatives, ensuring that important planned tasks don’t inadvertently become last-minute crises
My goal, and what I advocate, is to deliberately keep a significant portion of your planned work in the less urgent zones, creating the necessary ‘cushion’ to absorb inevitable, unplanned ‘Category A’ emergencies – the true critical incidents that demand immediate, singular focus.
The Compass also provides a clear ‘Order of Action,’ guiding your daily deployment of effort. It’s not about ticking off every single item by the end of the day; it’s about ensuring your energy is consistently directed towards the highest-impact work. This structured approach empowers you to make informed decisions about delegating, collaborating, and knowing when to escalate an issue if a deadline genuinely can’t be met.
Finally, a crucial component is ‘Thinking Ahead’. Many tasks require information gathering or input from others before you can fully engage. It’s a common mistake to simply set a final deadline and then ignore the task until it’s nearly due. The Priority Compass advises that for any task requiring advance preparation, you treat that preparation as a separate, prioritised component. This proactive step prevents those last-minute scrambles and keeps your workflow smooth.
Your Journey to Leadership Mastery
This ‘Priority Compass’ provides the foundational clarity. It’s designed to refine your leadership judgment and is adaptable, encouraging you to tailor its application to the unique complexities of your role and industry. The goal is to empower you to make more intentional, high-impact decisions about where your valuable time and energy are invested.
Download your own copy of the ‘Priority Compass’ here:
I’d love to hear your initial thoughts on this approach. How might you adapt these principles to the unique challenges within your own role
Level Up Leadership is a passion project in my spare time. I enjoy doing it, and I intend to keep these articles and podcasts free. However, the software and equipment I use isn’t free! So, if you are enjoying this content and would like to make a donation, you can do so by clicking this button. Thank you.